Evelyn, Mother, Emma
Ragtime has a very diverse cast of female characters, something I was surprised to encounter in an older book written by a male author, about even older times. Here, I want to focus on Evelyn Nesbit, Mother, and Emma Goldman. At first glance, each woman falls into some category of gender roles -- Evelyn as the provocative 'sex goddess,' Mother as the hardworking domestic housewife, and Emma as the radical, almost crazy feminist (I feel like plenty back then would have written her off as a 'feminazi,' in today's words). However, these ladies' stories are developed into multi-dimensional impressions of some very human, and very interesting women. They play into gender stereotypes, but their characters also fight against those stereotypes with their self-awareness that, somehow, is always tied to Emma Goldman.
Evelyn Nesbit is certainly a character. She's at the center of countless scandals -- assault, adultery, murder, even practically prostitution (Thaw gives her something like an allowance in return for her visits to his cell). She's beautiful, commonly believed to be the picture of American femininity, and has catapulted herself from rags to riches with her looks. There's countless Evelyn Nesbits in American literature; vapid, thoughtless bimbos written by men who play both the role of a fallen woman, villainess, and damsel in distress. But this Evelyn Nesbit has found self awareness. Having been in the spotlight from a young age, and even assaulted as a girl, she's grown into a hypersexualized woman who receives her gratification from male validation. She cannot resist Younger Brother's advances because of how obsessed with her he is, and the validation she consequentially gets. Her role in society is determined by her relationships with other men; most of her fame is even rom her romantic scandals. She gets thousands of dollars by lying in court. She's a 'creature of capitalism.' Emma Goldman at once laid these truths cold and clear to Evelyn, stripping her bare both literally and figuratively, and Evelyn's self awareness also becomes awareness for the reader, that the women like Evelyn Nesbit are victims of society, forced to find meaning in their lives by sexual attractiveness and physical beauty.
Mother is the picture of an American housewife, a mother. She doesn't even get a name -- she's just a woman whose identity is tied completely to motherhood. Her marriage is not truly a union of love, after all, she and Father seem to 'flourish in his absence.' Their sex scenes are quite possibly the saddest, unsexiest sex scenes ever written, with Mother detaching herself and carrying out an act of love as if it's a painful duty, while Father is enjoying himself. She's confined mostly to domestic duties -- that is, until Father's North Pole expedition. While he's gone, Mother spreads her wings quite a bit, becoming something of a businesswoman as she takes over the shop's executive duties in Father's stead. She discovers she's quite proficient and able to do the same things which had once seemed only her husband and other men could do. Once again, we find Emma Goldman's influence present, as Mother undergoes these changes while reading Emma Goldman. When Father comes back, their relationship is even more distant than before, and now with a sense of irreversible distance due to Mother's newfound independence. Mother exemplifies Goldman's beliefs, in a way, because she loses the constraints her marriage had once placed on her and expands her world with an independent perspective. Her role in the story as a domestic woman evolves to represent a journey of self-discovery.
Emma Goldman herself is the only character Doctorow seems to leave alone. She gets to speak for herself, gets to say her bit without any derision from a disembodied narrator. At first, she seems like the harebrained stereotype of a radical feminist, but Ragtime depicts her as the lone sane voice amongst plenty of madness. How ironic, yet fitting that the radical seen as a crazy anarchist by society speaks the most truth, with her ability to see the 'bigger picture' of many character's lives (think Evelyn and Younger Brother), and showing them a relentless honesty that come from a place of understanding and gentleness, not blame and scorn.
Ragtime does a good job with these women. They reflect stereotypes, yet not just that -- they reflect real women who have been forced into certain roles, and tell stories of realization and self-awareness that brings awareness to their oppression.
This was a really enjoyable read! I especially like your point about Evelyn Nesbit. I think this is what makes her such a fascinating character. He takes this legendary femme fatale and adds a bit of depth (lately through her relationships with Tateh, his daughter, and Goldman) without trying to force a contrived kind of redemption arc or turning over of a new leaf. She goes back to her old lifestyle, seemingly without a second thought. Except... she continues to donate to socialist and anarchist causes. It makes her something of an enigma.
ReplyDeleteI actually like Ragtime a lot for this reason - considering Doctorow is a male writing this book in the 20th century, there's a lot of female characters (at least compared to other novels written by men) and their portrayals are diverse yet accurate according to the time period. I think it's interesting that Doctorow has Emma Goldman be the closest thing to a voice of reason in the novel and this perplexed me in the first bit of the novel. However, her character has come to grow on me a bit as she inspires development in so many characters, either directly or indirectly. I also liked Evelyn Nesbit's character - it was nice that he doesn't make it look like she completely transformed over night. She has her feet in two worlds by staying in her upper class bubble after Tateh forsakes her but also helping out anarchist organizations. Great job on this post!
ReplyDeleteIncredible post! Doctorow allowing a central, powerful woman to help direct the lives of not just other women, but all surrounding her is catalyst for the feminist movement, both in the world of the characters and the real world. Emma Goldman touches the lives of several characters, such as Evelyn Nesbit, Mother, and Younger Brother. She pushes women to break the expectations held for them, such as when she tells Evelyn she needs not wear a corset or become a sexual being in order to please men/society. Goldman also pushes the men to recognize that women are not objects confined to a role. For example, she suggests to Younger Brother that his unattainable desire to be with Evelyn is destructive. Doctorow depicting such a strong individual in his novel urges readers to acknowledge feminism and the destruction of gender dynamics in society, thereby progressing feminism in the real world as well.
ReplyDeleteI like how you explain each of the female characters from the novel and give them descriptions and expand on how they've developed throughout the novel. I think it's interesting how all roads lead back to Emma Goldman when it comes to topics relating to women. I don't think everything Emma Goldman says is logical or rationale but she is the catalysts for character development amongst the female characters. Overall, I like how you organized your blog and characterized each female character.
ReplyDeleteI've said it in class, and I'll say it again here: Emma Goldman is an impressive and memorable character in this book due almost entirely to the actual facts of her life. Doctorow does little to "fictionalize" Goldman, and the portrait in his novel hews very close to her own self-portrait in her two-volume autobiography, _Living My Life_. Goldman's feminism and anarchism are so radical and uncompromising that many progressive readers today still won't be on board with everything she says, but the effect of free speech being wielded with such gusto is invigorating--reading Goldman is to constantly have your assumptions challenged, and even the most progressive reader will find themselves occasionally feeling insufficient to Goldman's extreme views. I'd say she's "ahead of her time," but in many ways we still haven't caught up with her. She earned her rep as "the most dangerous woman in America" solely through the use of her words and her exercise of her First Amendment rights (until, that is, she was deported to Russia for speaking too freely).
ReplyDeleteIf you're interested in Goldman and her historical era (as Doctorow clearly was), I recommend her memoir.